Looking for Bonnyview - Searching for the lakeshore home of a supermarket magnate
First Loblaws Groceteria at 2923 Dundas St W in the Junction (Source: Wikimedia Commons)
Years ago I learned that TP Loblaw – the Loblaw of supermarket fame – had once lived in Mimico. As time passed, I kept my eyes open but learned surprisingly little about the Loblaw family and their lakeshore home. I’ve discovered that there’s not much information online about the mansion. No pictures of it seem to exist in the public domain.
Theodore Pringle Loblaw was born in Elmgrove, Ontario, near Alliston, in 1872, the youngest of four children. His father, a farmer, died in an accident shortly afterwards and his mother passed away when he was 15. After attending high school in Alliston, Loblaw moved to Toronto and worked at William G. Cork’s grocery store. He saved his money and learned everything he could about the business.
A few years later he clerked at a store owned by Cork’s son, John Milton Cork, who became a lifelong friend. Loblaw married Isabella Adam in 1897 and purchased Cork’s store in 1900. He studied business at nights and started a small firm called the Loblaw Account System Company, which he sold in 1908.
In July 1910 Loblaw opened the first in what became a chain of 16 conventional grocery stores, which is to say all the goods were behind a counter and customers were served by clerks. A chain of stores meant lower prices for the consumer. He sold out to Dominion stores in 1919.
That same year, with J. Milton Cork as his partner, Loblaw opened the first self-serve grocery store in Canada. It had a turnstile entrance, goods placed on open shelves and a cashier at the exit. It resembled a cafeteria and was named a groceteria. The concept took off and, within 10 years, there were 99 Loblaw stores in Ontario served by a large warehouse at the foot of Bathurst Street. He expanded into the United States and had 50 stores in New York state. A similar venture in Chicago with 75 stores was sold to the Jewel Tea Company in 1932.
Theodore Pringle Loblaw was born in Elmgrove, Ontario, near Alliston, in 1872, the youngest of four children. His father, a farmer, died in an accident shortly afterwards and his mother passed away when he was 15. After attending high school in Alliston, Loblaw moved to Toronto and worked at William G. Cork’s grocery store. He saved his money and learned everything he could about the business.
A few years later he clerked at a store owned by Cork’s son, John Milton Cork, who became a lifelong friend. Loblaw married Isabella Adam in 1897 and purchased Cork’s store in 1900. He studied business at nights and started a small firm called the Loblaw Account System Company, which he sold in 1908.
In July 1910 Loblaw opened the first in what became a chain of 16 conventional grocery stores, which is to say all the goods were behind a counter and customers were served by clerks. A chain of stores meant lower prices for the consumer. He sold out to Dominion stores in 1919.
That same year, with J. Milton Cork as his partner, Loblaw opened the first self-serve grocery store in Canada. It had a turnstile entrance, goods placed on open shelves and a cashier at the exit. It resembled a cafeteria and was named a groceteria. The concept took off and, within 10 years, there were 99 Loblaw stores in Ontario served by a large warehouse at the foot of Bathurst Street. He expanded into the United States and had 50 stores in New York state. A similar venture in Chicago with 75 stores was sold to the Jewel Tea Company in 1932.
J. Milton Cork apparently introduced his friend and business partner to Mimico. Cork had been coming there for years but Might’s directory only shows him living there after 1924. Mimico had been the summer home of wealthy Torontonians since the 1870s and a number of estates had been established between Lake Shore Road and Lake Ontario.
Cork built a house at 77 Lake Shore Road, on the south side, just west of the Humber River. Land Registry records searched by Neil Park of the EHS Board show that TP Loblaw purchased a long narrow lot at 385 Lake Shore Road in June 1922 from Gertrude E. Nation. In December 1922 he followed up by purchasing an adjacent parcel on the lake from Margaret M. Kirkpatrick.
Loblaw’s neighbour to the north was Robert Wellington Eaton, the nephew of department store founder Timothy Eaton. RW Eaton was an Eaton’s company director and worked as superintendent of the store. He kept a summer home at 383 Lake Shore Road which, according to Land Registry records, he had owned since 1910.
Cork built a house at 77 Lake Shore Road, on the south side, just west of the Humber River. Land Registry records searched by Neil Park of the EHS Board show that TP Loblaw purchased a long narrow lot at 385 Lake Shore Road in June 1922 from Gertrude E. Nation. In December 1922 he followed up by purchasing an adjacent parcel on the lake from Margaret M. Kirkpatrick.
Loblaw’s neighbour to the north was Robert Wellington Eaton, the nephew of department store founder Timothy Eaton. RW Eaton was an Eaton’s company director and worked as superintendent of the store. He kept a summer home at 383 Lake Shore Road which, according to Land Registry records, he had owned since 1910.
An air photo from 1942. The Franceschini estate with its formal gardens is at the bottom. The curved driveway of the Loblaw estate is visible at the top of the frame. Bonnyview is below the end of the driveway nearest the road.
South of the Loblaw property was the estate of Sarah and Albert B. Ormsby, a wealthy manufacturer of metal windows and doors. Their mansion, called Ormscliffe, had been built in 1910 and the formal gardens, which stretched down to the lake, were designed by Howard and Lorrie Dunnington-Grubb who later founded Sheridan Nurseries.
TP Loblaw evidently built his own house in the mid-1920s. The address 385 Lake Shore Road first appears in Might’s directory in 1925. The mansion was said to have had 25 rooms including 7 bathrooms with beautiful oak flooring throughout. The Loblaws called it Bonnyview, perhaps because the property commanded a lovely prospect of Humber Bay with Toronto Island in the distance.
In 1925, TP Loblaw added to his holdings by purchasing the properties to the north and south. RW Eaton had bought a summer home in Muskoka and sold his Mimico estate in February 1925 to John T. Hutson. In May Hutson sold it to Loblaw. Albert and Sarah Ormsby, the neighbours to the south, retired to California in 1925 and sold their estate to James Franceschini, the owner of Dufferin Construction. But one parcel was sold by Ormsby to TP Loblaw for a reported $20,000, giving the Bonnyview estate a frontage of about 400 feet (122 metres) on Lake Shore Boulevard.
From air photos we can see the final layout of the Loblaw estate. The main house was located close to Lake Shore Road and an elegant, curved tree-lined driveway led to four cottages at the rear of the property where the staff lived.
TP Loblaw evidently built his own house in the mid-1920s. The address 385 Lake Shore Road first appears in Might’s directory in 1925. The mansion was said to have had 25 rooms including 7 bathrooms with beautiful oak flooring throughout. The Loblaws called it Bonnyview, perhaps because the property commanded a lovely prospect of Humber Bay with Toronto Island in the distance.
In 1925, TP Loblaw added to his holdings by purchasing the properties to the north and south. RW Eaton had bought a summer home in Muskoka and sold his Mimico estate in February 1925 to John T. Hutson. In May Hutson sold it to Loblaw. Albert and Sarah Ormsby, the neighbours to the south, retired to California in 1925 and sold their estate to James Franceschini, the owner of Dufferin Construction. But one parcel was sold by Ormsby to TP Loblaw for a reported $20,000, giving the Bonnyview estate a frontage of about 400 feet (122 metres) on Lake Shore Boulevard.
From air photos we can see the final layout of the Loblaw estate. The main house was located close to Lake Shore Road and an elegant, curved tree-lined driveway led to four cottages at the rear of the property where the staff lived.
Theodore Pringle Loblaw and his wife Isabella purchased more than six acres (2.5 ha) of land on Lake Shore Road in Mimico beginning in 1922. They soon built a mansion they called Bonnyview, overlooking Lake Ontario.
TP and Isabella had no children of their own but adopted a great-niece of his, Jean Agnes Loblaw, and fostered three nephews of hers, one of whom (Alexander Burr-Loblaw) later lived in Islington at 66 Burnhamthorpe Road. The family attended the Wesley United Church in Mimico.
Loblaw’s neighbour to the south was James Franceschini. Arriving as a penniless 15-year-old from Italy in 1905, Franceschini took a job no one else wanted – excavating basements. He made a success of his business and went on to found Dufferin Construction. On his Mimico estate, which he named Myrtle Villa after his daughter, Franceschini pursued his hobby of raising show horses. The horses would become a bone of contention with the Loblaws.
The Loblaw and Franceschini estates were separated by a road called Douglas Drive (later Douglas Boulevard). TP Loblaw had subdivided his lands fronting on Douglas into ten 50 foot (15.24 m) lots anchored by a park on Lake Ontario. But in 1925, before any of the lots were
sold, a building permit was issued for James Franceschini to build a large garage on the road. When the building was completed, it was used as a stable, which rendered Loblaw’s subdivision unsaleable.
TP and Isabella had no children of their own but adopted a great-niece of his, Jean Agnes Loblaw, and fostered three nephews of hers, one of whom (Alexander Burr-Loblaw) later lived in Islington at 66 Burnhamthorpe Road. The family attended the Wesley United Church in Mimico.
Loblaw’s neighbour to the south was James Franceschini. Arriving as a penniless 15-year-old from Italy in 1905, Franceschini took a job no one else wanted – excavating basements. He made a success of his business and went on to found Dufferin Construction. On his Mimico estate, which he named Myrtle Villa after his daughter, Franceschini pursued his hobby of raising show horses. The horses would become a bone of contention with the Loblaws.
The Loblaw and Franceschini estates were separated by a road called Douglas Drive (later Douglas Boulevard). TP Loblaw had subdivided his lands fronting on Douglas into ten 50 foot (15.24 m) lots anchored by a park on Lake Ontario. But in 1925, before any of the lots were
sold, a building permit was issued for James Franceschini to build a large garage on the road. When the building was completed, it was used as a stable, which rendered Loblaw’s subdivision unsaleable.
In the fall of 1926, TP Loblaw took his complaints to Mimico’s town council, which refused to act. He told the newspapers that he had no ill-will toward anyone, he just wanted to get the problem resolved. He suggested that new stables be built on the other side of the Franceschini property, and the existing building be used for other purposes. His neighbour refused.
In 1927 Loblaw sued the Town of Mimico and the Franceschini family, seeking a declaration that Douglas Drive was not a public road, but was in fact part of the lands he had purchased from the former owners, the Ormsbys, in 1925. The lawsuit ultimately failed and no
houses were ever built on Douglas Drive.
Isabella Loblaw died of heart disease in 1930. TP Loblaw was only 60 in 1933 when he entered hospital for a minor sinus operation. He developed meningitis and died a few days later. A deeply religious man, Loblaw had given many substantial donations during his lifetime
including $100,000 to establish a hospital in Alliston and, along with J. Milton Cork, had given $1,000,000 to Toronto Western Hospital. His estate, valued at more than $2,000,000, also benefitted the University of Toronto and other institutions.
In 1927 Loblaw sued the Town of Mimico and the Franceschini family, seeking a declaration that Douglas Drive was not a public road, but was in fact part of the lands he had purchased from the former owners, the Ormsbys, in 1925. The lawsuit ultimately failed and no
houses were ever built on Douglas Drive.
Isabella Loblaw died of heart disease in 1930. TP Loblaw was only 60 in 1933 when he entered hospital for a minor sinus operation. He developed meningitis and died a few days later. A deeply religious man, Loblaw had given many substantial donations during his lifetime
including $100,000 to establish a hospital in Alliston and, along with J. Milton Cork, had given $1,000,000 to Toronto Western Hospital. His estate, valued at more than $2,000,000, also benefitted the University of Toronto and other institutions.
J. Milton Cork took over the operation of the Loblaws grocery chain and sold his shares to Garfield Weston in 1947. By 1953 George Weston Limited had acquired a controlling interest in the company.
TP Loblaw’s daughter, Jean, sold Bonnyview to a company called Construction Sales Co. Ltd. in June 1943. They, in turn, sold it to James Franceschini’s Dufferin Construction Company in two parts in December 1944 and March 1945. After standing empty for a year, the house was rented to Mimico’s town council in 1946 for use as temporary emergency housing. It was remodelled into seven three-room apartments and by 1949, nine families, including 17 children, were living on the former Loblaw estate.
Dufferin Construction wanted to sell the property and in January 1949 requested that Mimico mayor Archie Norris find alternative accommodation for the tenants. This caused a storm of protest. In March some families had left but 6 barricaded themselves in their apartments and vowed to stay. More housing slowly became available. By June there were only three families remaining and by the year’s end they too were gone.
Bonnyview was demolished during the first half of 1950. Small ads appeared in the Toronto Star in March and May. The first advertised, “Wrecking Beautiful Loblaw Estate 385 Lake Shore Road – Come and look around – doors, windows, stairs, lumber, oak flooring, hot
water heating systems….” The second said, “Bricks, bricks, bricks from Loblaw estate – good hard face bricks and inside bricks, doors, windows and lumber also for sale….”
Once the house was gone, Norris Crescent was built on the former Loblaw property and 18 sixplexes were constructed there. The ones on the north side of the street, where Bonnyview once stood, now comprise the Norris Crescent Housing Cooperative, which provides affordable apartments for local families.
TP Loblaw’s daughter, Jean, sold Bonnyview to a company called Construction Sales Co. Ltd. in June 1943. They, in turn, sold it to James Franceschini’s Dufferin Construction Company in two parts in December 1944 and March 1945. After standing empty for a year, the house was rented to Mimico’s town council in 1946 for use as temporary emergency housing. It was remodelled into seven three-room apartments and by 1949, nine families, including 17 children, were living on the former Loblaw estate.
Dufferin Construction wanted to sell the property and in January 1949 requested that Mimico mayor Archie Norris find alternative accommodation for the tenants. This caused a storm of protest. In March some families had left but 6 barricaded themselves in their apartments and vowed to stay. More housing slowly became available. By June there were only three families remaining and by the year’s end they too were gone.
Bonnyview was demolished during the first half of 1950. Small ads appeared in the Toronto Star in March and May. The first advertised, “Wrecking Beautiful Loblaw Estate 385 Lake Shore Road – Come and look around – doors, windows, stairs, lumber, oak flooring, hot
water heating systems….” The second said, “Bricks, bricks, bricks from Loblaw estate – good hard face bricks and inside bricks, doors, windows and lumber also for sale….”
Once the house was gone, Norris Crescent was built on the former Loblaw property and 18 sixplexes were constructed there. The ones on the north side of the street, where Bonnyview once stood, now comprise the Norris Crescent Housing Cooperative, which provides affordable apartments for local families.
Researched and Written by Richard Jordan